Double Apple Pie With a Twist

Double Apple Pie With a Twist


This is a healthier version of the regular apple pie because it uses jaggery powder instead of sugar and you wont even know the difference. It came about after my younger child was laid up with a terrible bout of allergy related respiratory infections and the poor baby has not been allowed to eat any candy or desserts as sugar makes a sore throat and chest infections even worse. Jaggery on the other hand, actually helps to clear the chest. Therefore, with so many food and fruit restrictions, I’m adapting my desserts to replace sugar and add ingredients she is allowed to have.

Here I’ve used a combination of Granny Smith apples, which have a sour tart flavour and Fuji apples which have a sweet flavour. The two apple varieties are also firm fleshed so they do not dissolve into mush while cooking. I didn’t use any lemon juice as the Granny Smith apples have enough of a tang on their own. All my desserts generally have less sugar and sweeteners as I try to get away with the minimum amount required to make it palatable but as jaggery is not as sweet as sugar, you may want to add more.

I’ve used organic jaggery powder here. Jaggery comes in two forms. Light brown and dark brown. The dark brown one has a concentrated treacly taste and the light brown jaggery is less intense. I’ve used the light brown powder here. In India, jaggery is called Gur and the powder is called shakkar. It’s available in abundance in the winter months so better to stock up and keep in airtight containers for the rest of the year if you think it’s not going to be available later.

Jaggery Powder

I’m on a mission to try and replace white sugar as much as possible in my desserts. Of course, any replacement will still have the calories, but then instead of empty calories and harmful effects, alternatives like jaggery and honey have nutritional value and health benefits. Jaggery, made with sugarcane juice, has a host of minerals and salts that apparently clear your lungs, stomach, intestines, purify the blood and even relieves constipation if taken in small amounts on a regular basis. Diabetics of course have to refrain.

If you think you want to try something interesting and different, you can try this.


For the Pie Base (shortcrust pastry)

300 gms flour
3 heaped tbsp jaggery (shakkar) powder (add more if you want it sweeter)
Pinch of salt
150 gms butter cut into 1 cm cubes and chilled
2 eggs whisked

For the Filling

6 apples (4 Granny Smith and 2 Fuji) peeled and sliced finely
4 heaped tbsp jaggery powder
1 heaped tsp cinnamon powder
50 gms walnuts roughly chopped (optional)

Get Started (pictorial steps below)

Pie Base

  • In a large mixing bowl, add the jaggery powder and salt to the flour and mix. Then add the chilled butter and rub the butter into the flour till the mixture resembles fine bread crumbs.
  • Add three fourths of the beaten eggs (leaving the rest for brushing on the pastry later) to the flour mixture and mix together gently till the flour clumps together. Do not knead into a hard dough.
  • Wrap the pastry in cling film flatten into a circular disc and chill in the fridge for at least half an hour.

For a detailed pictorial idea of how to make a pie base go here. Please follow only the basic pictorial instructions up to the rolling part but follow the recipe in this post. This recipe has some modifications.

Pie filling

  • Place the sliced apples along with the cinnamon and jaggery powder in a heavy bottomed pan and heat on medium flame for about 10 minutes, turning gently every once in a while to make sure all the apples are softened and coated well with the cinnamon and jaggery. Do not overcook as you only want the apples to stop releasing their water. Once softened set aside to cool.


  • Preheat your oven to 180° centigrade with only the bottom heating rods on.
  • Take out the pastry after chilling and cut off about 2/3 of it and place it between 2 sheets of cling film and with a rolling pin (belan) roll into a circle large enough to cover a 9 inch diameter tart case. The pastry should be about 2 mm thick. Pull off the top sheet of cling film and invert the pastry onto the pie tin making sure to have a fair amount topping the sides. Remove the top layer of cling film.
  • Chill the pie case with the pastry in the refrigerator and begin rolling the remaining 1/3 of the pastry between two sheets of cling film to cover the pie on top. Put the cover in the refrigerator with the cling film.
  • Take out the pie tin and pour the softened apple filling into it, making sure to spread the apples evenly. Throw in the walnuts, then cover it with the remaining dough and fold in the sides of the pie crust to seal the edges of the pie. Poke the top of the pie crust with a fork all over or make decorative holes to allow steam to escape while baking.
  • Brush the top of the pie liberally with the remaining beaten egg.
  • Bake in the centre rack of the oven for 45 minutes. Remove from oven, let it cool for a bit. Eat the pie warm or cold.
  • If you have leftovers, place them in an airtight container and keep out in a cool place or if in warm climate, in the refrigerator. Do not microwave to reheat, the crust will become soggy. Cover with foil and bake in a preheated oven for 20 minutes for the best taste.

Important notes: Keep the butter chilled for the pastry and keep the pastry chilled after rolling and before baking. Pastry tends to melt and become a mushy mess in hot climates and will shrink with melted butter. The chilled butter and chilled pastry will give it a firm and crisp texture and will not shrink.

Use only the heating rods at the bottom of the oven for this. If you have an oven where you don’t have the option of turning the rods on the top off, you can place an oven tray between the rod and the pie. Direct heat from the top will end up burning the top crust before the bottom has a chance to cook.

Do not overcook the apples. You want them to hold their shape and not become a mushy mess.

Pictorial Steps

This Post Has One Comment

  1. Trishna

    Yummmmm ….sounds good….I make an apple crumble…doing away with the pie crust all together….is delicious…as well. But maybe for a good treat ..I will try this one and eat it all by myself.

Leave a Reply